Anne Hathaway chose another New York Knicks championship over winning a second Oscar during her September 30, 2026 appearance on The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon. The pregnant actor was promoting Verity when Jimmy Fallon made her pick between two of her biggest loves. Hathaway's Knicks loyalty has been extra loud since The Devil Wears Prada 2 premiered on May 1 with a scene featuring her character and Knicks star Karl Anthony Towns. After the Knicks launched a 13 game winning streak, fans jokingly treated Hathaway as the team's good luck charm. Oscar gold or Knicks glory? Fallon's game forced Hathaway to choose between another Oscar and a Knicks title. Hathaway is considered a best supporting actress contender for her performance in The Odyssey, but the New York City native still picked the championship, admitting that the decision made her nervous system react intensely. The Tonight Show segment also delivered a Knicks fan's dream gift. The team sent Hathaway a signed OG Anunoby jersey plus baby gifts and a note from Anunoby, whose near collision with Hathaway and her son at a November 2024 game helped inspire her public fandom. Hathaway immediately put on the jersey and appeared far more interested in her new Knicks loot than in answering Fallon's questions.