Jennifer Aniston and hypnotist Jim Curtis are facing mixed reviews from Aniston’s inner circle, according to Page Six sources. The couple sparked romance rumors in July 2025 after being photographed together on Spain’s Mallorca island, and some friends reportedly remain cautious about Curtis nearly a year later. One source claimed that certain people close to Aniston worry Curtis could be pursuing the relationship for personal gain and said his public persona can feel “performative.” The source added that Aniston’s friends are protective of the 57 year old actor and want to avoid seeing her taken advantage of. Not Everyone Is Sounding the Alarm Another insider offered a much sunnier read, telling Page Six that several friends have embraced Curtis and believe he fits naturally into Aniston’s social circle. That source said Aniston appears happier than she has been in a long time and that the pair complement each other. The conflicting assessments suggest Aniston’s friends are not operating from one unanimous group chat. Some reportedly have trouble fully trusting Curtis, while others are rooting for the 57 year old Friends star and the 50 year old transformational coach. Representatives for Aniston and Curtis did not immediately respond to Page Six’s requests for comment. For now, the relationship remains a public romance with private opinions swirling around it, and the only confirmed takeaway is that Aniston’s circle is watching closely.